Ready for a kitchen upgrade? Should you reface or replace your cabinets?
When it comes to upgrading your kitchen, you have two main choices: refacing or replacing your kitchen cabinets. But how do you decide which option is best for you?
Mohammed Bharucha, a renovation expert at Doorfinder, offers his advice on the key differences and how to make the right decision for your home when planning a kitchen makeover.
Everything you need to know about refacing your kitchen cabinets
Here’s everything you need to know about refacing your kitchen cabinets.
What is refacing?
Refacing kitchen cabinets involves replacing the cabinet doors and drawer fronts while keeping the existing cabinet boxes intact.
This process gives you the opportunity to update the style of your kitchen by swapping out the visible parts of the cabinetry, while retaining the sturdy structure underneath. You could also update handles, doorknobs and trim, which enhances the overall aesthetic without the need for a complete overhaul.
Refacing is the better option for homeowners looking to stay on-trend without the hefty price tag of a full replacement; it allows for easy updates with modern materials, finishes and hardware to achieve a fresh, stylish look without committing to a complete remodel.
The pros of refacing your kitchen cabinets
Here are some pros of refacing your kitchen cabinets.
1) Cost-effective
Refacing is more affordable than replacing your kitchen cabinets entirely. You’re only paying for the visible parts of the cabinet, typically one-third to half the price of a full replacement. It’s a great option if you’re working with a tighter budget but still want a kitchen that feels brand new.
2) Eco-friendly
Refacing is a more environmentally responsible choice since you’re not throwing away entire cabinets. If the base units are still in good condition, you’re saving material and reducing waste. This can be an excellent way to refresh your kitchen while being mindful of your carbon footprint.
3) Quick turnaround
If you’re on a tight timeline, refacing your kitchen cabinets offers a faster solution. The lead time for manufacturing new cabinet fronts is quicker than ordering a full new set, typically 2-3 weeks, versus 6-8 weeks for an entire kitchen. This makes refacing ideal for a renovation project that needs to be completed in a shorter period.
4) Highly customisable
Refacing offers you a wide variety of styles, colours and finishes to choose from. This gives you full control over the design, allowing you to create a kitchen that matches your personal style.
The cons of refacing your kitchen cabinets
And here are some of the cons of refacing your kitchen cabinets.
1) Limited layout changes
Refacing only addresses the external aspects of your kitchen cabinets, so if you’re considering a layout change or need to adjust the functionality of your space, refacing may not be the best choice. You are stuck with the existing configuration, so make sure it works for you before committing to this option.
2) Not always cost-effective long term
If your cabinets are already in poor condition, or if you foresee needing a complete redesign in the near future, refacing might not be a smart investment. The cost savings could be offset by the need for more extensive work later on.
3) Not always suitable for all styles
Refacing works best when you have quality cabinets that are still in good shape. If your cabinets are outdated or have structural issues, it might be better to invest in a full replacement rather than refacing them.
Reface your kitchen cabinets if:
- You have a functional, well-built kitchen but want a fresh look.
- You are on a budget and need a more affordable option than full replacement.
- You’re looking to enhance your home’s value before selling, especially if your kitchen cabinets are still in good condition.
Everything you need to know about replacing your kitchen cabinets
Here’s everything you need to know about replacing your kitchen cabinets.
What is replacing?
Replacing kitchen cabinets involves completely removing the existing units and installing new ones.
When you opt to replace your cabinets, you’re starting from scratch, with both the frames and the fronts being replaced. This is often part of a larger renovation project where the kitchen layout is being reworked.
The structure of a kitchen cabinet, including the frame and core components, should last anywhere between 20 to 30 years, provided it is properly maintained. High-quality cabinets made from solid wood or sturdy composite materials can last the longest, while cheaper or poorly constructed options may wear out more quickly. Regular maintenance, such as cleaning and addressing any small issues like loose hinges or minor damage, can help extend the life of your cabinet structure.
The pros of replacing your kitchen cabinets
Here are some pros of replacing your kitchen cabinets.
1) Complete control over layout and storage
Replacing your cabinets gives you complete flexibility to redesign the entire layout of your kitchen. You can optimise storage, choose new materials, and create a more functional, bespoke kitchen that suits your needs.
2) Higher property value
A modern, newly fitted kitchen can significantly increase your home’s value. Potential buyers are likely to be attracted to a newly installed kitchen, making it a worthwhile investment if you’re looking to sell.
3) Long-term investment
If you know that you’re going to be in your home long term, investing in a full kitchen replacement ensures that you’ll have a space you truly love. It’s an opportunity to create a dream kitchen that will last for years.
The cons of replacing your kitchen cabinets
Here are some cons of replacing your kitchen cabinets.
1) Expensive and disruptive
Replacing kitchen cabinets is a more costly and time-consuming process than refacing. The entire kitchen has to be removed and replaced, which can cause disruption to your home life for weeks, and costs for new cabinetry and installation are significantly higher than refacing.
2) Longer lead times
The manufacturing and delivery of new cabinets can take several weeks. You may also need to account for other work like plumbing or electrical changes, which can delay the process further.
Replace your kitchen cabinets if:
- Your cabinets are outdated, damaged or no longer functional.
- You want to make significant changes to your kitchen’s layout and design.
- You plan on staying in the home for the long term and want a space that suits your lifestyle.
Making the right decision for your kitchen
For those looking to stretch their home improvement budget further in 2025, it’s essential to weigh both the cost and long-term value of refacing versus replacing. Mohammed suggests considering factors such as the condition of your current cabinets, how long you plan to stay in your home, and the overall aesthetic you want to achieve.
If you’re looking for an affordable way to update your kitchen, refacing is a great option. But if you want a complete overhaul with more control over the layout and design, replacing your cabinets will give you the results you’re after.
Ultimately, the choice comes down to your needs and how much of a change you want in your kitchen.Should you reface or replacing your kitchen cabinets?
